Selling Your Coin Collection: 7 Useful Things You Need To Know

Photo of author
Written By Natasha Jones
I'm Natasha Jones, an avid collector of coins, stamps, and paper money. My passion drives me to seek unique finds, from antique shops to international exchanges. I enjoy connecting with fellow collectors through forums and meet-ups, sharing discoveries and insights. Collecting, for me, is about preserving history and building a community around this shared interest.

So you are thinking of selling your coin collections, is it worth it? Are there any risks to it? There have been many coin collectors who have sold their collections, only to regret the decision later. This is because they underestimate the value of their coins and end up selling them for less than what they are worth. On the other hand, there are also those entrepreneurs who buy these collections hoping to resell them later at a better price. In both cases, it’s important to know what you’re getting into before deciding whether to sell or buy coins as an investment!

Things To Remember When Selling/Buying Coins?

When you’re buying or selling coins, there are some things to remember:

  1. Be careful not to get scammed.
  2. Make sure you know what you’re buying and selling.
  3. Be careful about who you buy from and sell to.

How Can You Avoid Getting Scammed When Buying/Selling Coins?


When buying or selling coins, there are some basic things to keep in mind: Know what you are buying. This one seems obvious, but it’s worth highlighting because there are many possible pitfalls.

If you’re buying a coin collection from someone else, make sure they have the authority to sell the collection (e.g., it belongs to them). Also, check that everything in their catalog is true and correct. While you can’t always trust people who list coin collections for sale online, if something doesn’t seem right, don’t purchase from that person!

Know the value of what you’re buying/selling. In other words, know whether or not this item is worth more than its face value. For example: if your grandmother gives you an ancient coin collection with several rare gold coins in it (that she has kept safe since childhood), those coins could be worth thousands or tens of thousands of dollars!

How To Know the Value of Coin Collection when selling coin collection?

So, you’re considering selling your coin collection, but how do you know if your coin collection is worth anything? The value of a coin collection is determined by three factors: rarity, condition, and demand.

Rarity refers to the number of coins produced for that particular year/era. For example, if only 100 quarters were minted in 1982 and 100 collectors want them, but only ten exist today, then that quarter would be considered rare and thus valuable.


Condition refers to how much wear and tear individual coins have experienced over time. A coin with no scratches or dents may not be considered as valuable as one that has been passed around by several people for years on end before ending up in your hands—and vice versa: if you find one with tons of scratches all over it but no dents then it might still be worth money!


Demand refers to how many collectors are looking for specific types or species of coins at any given time; this can change drastically depending on what’s going on with current events (like Brexit).


If you want a rough estimate of your coin collection worth, try selling it through an auction house or on eBay. You can also consult one of the many online guides offering information on the most valuable coins.

Where Can You Sell Your Coin Collection?

Selling coin collections can be done in a variety of ways. Several options are available, from the tried-and-true to the more modern. Let’s take a look at each one:

Coin Dealers: If you want to sell coins quickly and for the best price possible, we recommend taking them to a reputable local dealer specializing in coins and currency. When selling your coins through a coin dealer, you will likely be able to get more cash for them than if you were to sell them at an auction or on eBay. The drawback is that dealers often charge high fees (upwards of 15%) and don’t always pay top dollar for rare coins (often just wholesale prices). However, they offer immediate cash payment, so it might be worth considering if speed is essential!


Coin Shows: Many people find success selling their collections at local coin shows where plenty of people look for collectibles like yours on display or up for auction. You can often get good deals if you’re buying other items, too, such as books about collecting antique coins or jewelry made using precious metals like gold or silver–so make sure your budget allows room for these extra purchases before heading out there!

Online Auctions: Selling your coins on eBay or other similar websites is another way to get top dollar for them. You’ll need to set up an account and pay a small listing fee per item (typically around 10%), but you can expect to get more cash than if you were to sell them through a local coin dealer or at a coin show because there are far more buyers browsing these sites than there are in person.


Why Do They Buy Coin Collections?

There are 2 main reasons why people buy coin collections. They buy them to make money, they buy them to add to their collection, and they buy them to make a profit.

  • To Make Money
    • Your coins may be worth more than you think! A good way of finding out what your collection is worth is by putting together an online auction on eBay or another website that sells coins and collectibles. You’ll have access to millions of potential buyers worldwide who can help you sell your collection for top dollar.
  • To Add to Their Collections
    • Some collectors will only purchase a coin if it’s something new or rare; this means that if you have an old set from the ’50s that has been sitting somewhere in your house collecting dust, they probably won’t want it. If this is the case, think about starting an “everything but the kitchen sink” sale where anyone can grab whatever items they like (except those kitchen sinks!). This will help clear out some space while ensuring nothing goes unwanted!

Is There A Best Way in Selling Coin Collection?

If you’re selling coin collection, the best way is to find a reputable dealer. There are several reasons why this is true. First, reputable dealers will pay the most for your coins, but this is not always the case.

They also have more experience in buying and selling these kinds of collectibles so that they can offer you the best price for them. Finally, reputable dealers will buy coin collections that are in good condition. If you want your collection to be worth as much as possible when it gets sold, ensure every piece is in good shape before taking it anywhere else!

Before you go…

I hope this article helped you answer questions on selling coin collections. It’s not easy to sell coin collections, but it is possible if you research and find the right buyer. Avoid scams by looking for a reputable dealer or auction house specializing in coins. While there may be many options for selling your collection, it’s best to go with someone who has been around for a while and has built up a reputation as an honest businessman.

Check out my next article: “Should You Sell Your Coin Collection? The Pros & Cons

Related Articles:

3 thoughts on “Selling Your Coin Collection: 7 Useful Things You Need To Know”

  1. I’ve had most of these coins for30plus yeqrs. Along with many other things I just got them out and I’m researching but I’m just not sure that I’m understanding the terms they use . I want to sell some them but I don’t want to sell a coin or a stamp and be mistaken in what I’m selling. I see the term on eBay used. Uncertified. Should I do that? Any advice would be appreciated can’t afford to have them appraised.

    • These are my suggestions

      1) check the condition of your coin and compare it to an appraised coin
      2) go to a local shop and ask them how much for the coins. Don’t go to one shop, check several shops and get a rough estimation.

      You can then sell it to either your local shop or at eBay.

    • How would you recommend finding reputable dealer or collector? I’ve been sitting on my coins for years and I don’t really trust anyone so far. I would like to sell my collection. Is there someone you recommend?
      Thank you!


Leave a Comment