Should You Sell Your Coin Collection? The Pros & Cons

Photo of author
Written By Natasha Jones
I'm Natasha Jones, an avid collector of coins, stamps, and paper money. My passion drives me to seek unique finds, from antique shops to international exchanges. I enjoy connecting with fellow collectors through forums and meet-ups, sharing discoveries and insights. Collecting, for me, is about preserving history and building a community around this shared interest.

Should you sell your coin collection? Trading, selling, and buying coins is one of the world’s oldest hobbies.

People have been collecting coins for thousands of years – some still collect them today! But should you sell your coin collection?

This can be a tough question to answer.

If you’re thinking about selling your coin collection, there are several things that you need to consider carefully before making any decisions.

Should You Sell Your Coin Collection?

Should you sell your coin collection? Selling your coin collection can be a great way to turn your hard-earned money into something more.

You might have a few coins lying around, or you could have an entire collection that you’ve been building for years.

Whichever the case may be, selling it is an option that should always be considered if it will bring in some extra cash.

Several options exist if you want to sell your coin collection but don’t know where to start.

You can sell them on eBay and other sites like Amazon and Etsy, where people purchase items from individuals worldwide; however, these can take some time and effort (and sometimes even require shipping costs).

Another option is local dealers who specialize in buying collectibles of all kinds—they often pay more than online buyers since they buy in bulk, so they’ll need as much product as possible!

You can also try collector’s auctions or garage sales where people look specifically at what they’re seeking versus those who buy upon items while browsing through various markets like flea markets or antique stores.”

Advantages of Selling Coin Collection?

Make Money

12 5

This may be the most obvious reason to sell your coin collection, but it’s also the best.

As you can see from our chart above, even common coins are worth a lot of money in large quantities.

And rare coins can be worth tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands!

Getting Rid of Coins, You Don’t Want to Keep

13 4

Selling your coin collection is a great way to clean out all those old pennies that have been sitting around forever without being used.

Since they’re essentially worthless anyway, it’s better to get some cash for them rather than having them lying around gathering dust and taking up space in your home or office closet.

Plus, since selling is such an easy process with just about any reputable coin dealer (and you’ll get paid quickly), it won’t take long before these unwanted coins go forever!

Storage or Theft

You don’t have to worry about storage space or theft of your collection anymore.

Either if it were stored at home or workplace due to the risk associated with keeping valuable coins in a safe deposit box at the bank, which may be robbed by thieves when they are left unattended for too long during work hours while employees are busy doing their jobs or handling other tasks and responsibilities of employment.

They might even become vulnerable to burglars who break into homes through windows outdoors and sneak right through the doors indoors while residents sleep off after returning from work early in the morning.

When all these things happen, we’d rather see them safely locked up inside secure vaults where nobody can touch them without permission from owners with access cards that need swiping for the validation programming system before entering.

Disadvantages of Selling Coin Collection?


Selling your collection is an excellent option if you want to make some money from your old coins.

However, there are some disadvantages that you should know about first.

  1. You might not get what you want for them. The value of coins can change over time, and there’s no guarantee that the person who buys them will pay what they’re worth. If this happens, you might lose money when all is said and done!
  2. Finding someone willing to buy your collection at all can be challenging. Some people don’t collect old coins because they think they’re worth less than their face value; others may not have enough space in their homes to store extensive collections like yours (I’m looking at YOU here!). So even if someone agrees with me when I say, “this is a steal!” – which it is – they still might not be able to take advantage of it for those reasons.* Even if someone does agree on our price point, we still have another hurdle: getting paid in cash instead of bartering services or goods.* And finally. If everything goes according to plan, and we find a buyer who meets all four criteria listed above (and then some), then

Should You Sell Your Coin Collection? Is It Worth It?

If you’re thinking of selling your coin collection, here are some points to keep in mind:

  1. If you’re not interested in the hobby anymore, sell it! You might be surprised how much money some coins are worth.
  2. If you need the cash, go ahead and sell—but make sure it’s not an emergency requiring immediate funds. A few weeks’ delays won’t make a difference compared to selling out of desperation and regretting it later.
  3. And suppose you want to invest in something else (like stocks or bonds). In that case, there’s no better way than by unloading what’s been collecting dust for so long: cash flow problems will immediately disappear once those coins are sold off for a reasonable price. Whatever profit comes from those sales can be used toward other investments with a higher potential for success (hopefully less risk).

If any of these three scenarios apply to your situation right now—selling because interest has waned, needing more money fast, wanting new ways of making money—then definitely consider selling off some old coins!

Tips on Selling your coins


If you have a collection you’ve been considering selling, there are a few things to remember.

  1. First, do your research! If you’re unsure how much your coins are worth, look at coin and price guides online. Many reputable coin dealers can help you understand what types of coins might be valuable and which aren’t worth as much. You may be surprised by how much some old coins could potentially sell for!
  1. Next, be aware of the market. The best way to do this is by keeping up with trends in both collecting and selling (visit our blog for more information). Also, check out other people’s collections on social media or online forums; these places often feature pictures that show off all sorts of interesting finds—including rare items that fetch high prices on the secondary market. It’s always good practice because it’ll give us an idea of what others consider valuable and because learning from others’ successes will allow us to learn from their mistakes too!
  1. Finally, make sure we know what we’re getting into before going full speed ahead with any decisions like this one since they tend towards being irreversible once made.

Before you go…

I hope this article helped you answer questions about whether you should sell your coin collection. Selling your collection is a great way to make extra cash, but it’s not for everyone. Be sure to weigh all your options before deciding whether or not this is right for you. If you don’t think selling is worth it, there are plenty of other ways to use your coin collection at home!

Check out my next article: “Selling Your Coin Collection: 7 Useful Things You Need To Know.”

Related Articles:

Leave a Comment