Where to Find The Best Places to Sell Coins in 2026

1. GreatCollections

GreatCollections is a premier online coin auction platform specializing in certified coins and currency.

Founded in 2010, they conduct weekly auctions featuring PCGS, NGC, CAC, and ANACS certified coins, with prices ranging from $25 to over $250,000.

Pros:

• Industry-leading fee structure—0% seller’s fees for coins over $1,000; only 5% for coins under $1,000
• Fast payment within 10-14 days after the auction closes
• Free professional photography and listing for all consignments
• No minimum value requirements—accepts coins from $25 and up
• Extensive auction archive with over 1.7 million price records for research
• Discounted grading rates at PCGS, NGC, and ANACS for consignors
• Weekly auctions provide consistent selling opportunities

Cons:

• Auction format only—no “buy it now” option for buyers wanting immediate purchase
• Best results with certified coins; raw coins may not perform as well
• Must ship your coins to them before listing
• Smaller international buyer base compared to Heritage Auctions
• Lower-value or common coins may receive less attention in large weekly auctions

Heritage Auction

Heritage is one of the world’s largest and most respected auction houses, with a strong focus on numismatics.

Founded in 1976, they’ve built an unmatched reputation in the coin-collecting community over nearly five decades.

Pros:

• Live auction features attract serious collectors worldwide
• Nearly 50 years of established reputation and credibility
• Massive database of buyers actively seeking coin collections
• Welcomes collectors at all experience levels
• Excellent knowledge base for beginners learning about coin investing
• A professional team handles listing and marketing for you

Cons:

• Payment hold period of at least 45 days before funds are released
• 10% commission fee on sales
• You must ship your coins to Heritage for evaluation and auction
• High-value coins receive significantly more attention than lower-value items

Modern Coin Mart

Modern Coin Mart operates with a direct purchase model—similar to a pawnshop but specialized in coins and precious metals.

They buy your coins outright and then resell them at a profit. For coins valued under $3,000, you’ll receive payment via check.

Pros:

• Guaranteed buyer—no waiting to find the right collector
• Professional team handles all the work
• Established since 2004 with over 20 years of trusted service
• Strong reputation attracts confident buyers to their platform

Cons:

• Must ship coins first before receiving payment
• Lower offers since they need profit margin when reselling
• Not ideal if you want to maximize value through competitive bidding

APMEX

APMEX (American Precious Metals Exchange) follows a similar business model to Modern Coin Mart.

Founded in 2000, they’ve grown into one of the world’s largest online precious metals and coin dealers over their 25+ years in business.

Pros:

• Professional listing and marketing services
• Established reputation with over 25 years of experience
• Guaranteed buyer for your coins
• Fast payment—typically the next business day after your coins arrive

Cons:

• $1,000 minimum value requirement—won’t accept anything below that threshold
• Must ship coins before receiving payment
• Like Modern Coin Mart, their purchase offers factor in their resale margins

eBay

eBay provides access to a massive global marketplace. With approximately 135 million active buyers worldwide as of 2024, it offers unmatched reach for sellers willing to manage their own listings and customer service.

Pros:

• Complete control over pricing
• Enormous potential buyer base
• Flexible selling options—auction or fixed price
• Familiar platform most people already know how to use

Cons:

• Listing fees can add up, especially for higher-priced items
• Not specialized for coins, so serious collectors may look elsewhere first
• Higher risk dealing with unknown buyers
• Potential for counterfeit coins among listings reduces buyer confidence
• No expert authentication or grading services