Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them, GrandCollector may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The 1856 Flying Eagle cent is the first small cent the United States Mint produced, and it is the hardest date in the three-year series to find. The reason is more specific than the auction prices suggest.
The design lasted only three years, from 1856 to 1858, and the 1856 date carries the smallest production of the three. How much of that scarcity actually survives today is the part worth checking before you pay.
Key Takeaways:
1. At least 634 pieces were struck in 1856 and handed to members of Congress and other officials to promote the new small cent.
2. Restrikes from the original dies mean a coin dated 1856 is not automatically one of those 634 originals.
3. Price tracks grade and surface quality, and the top auction result stands at $312,000 for a Proof 67+ example.
History of the 1856 Flying Eagle Cent

The Flying Eagle Cent was first minted in 1856 and was designed by James Barton Longacre, who was then the Chief Engraver of the United States Mint.
This coin was introduced to replace the large cent, which was too heavy and cumbersome for everyday use.
The Flying Eagle Cent was smaller and lighter, making it more convenient for commerce.
The 1856 Flying Eagle Cent was the first year of issue and was only struck in limited quantities.
The coin was made of copper-nickel and had a diameter of 19mm and a weight of 4.7 grams.
The obverse of the coin featured an eagle in flight, hence the name Flying Eagle Cent.
The reverse of the coin featured a wreath surrounding the denomination of “one cent.”
The Flying Eagle cent was produced only from 1856 to 1858, when the Indian Head cent took over.
Despite its short production run, the Flying Eagle Cent remains a popular coin among collectors.
Rarity explains most of the attention.
634 pieces were struck in 1856 for distribution to Congress and other officials, against millions of cents dated 1857 and 1858.
Survivors also tend to be worn, which pushes up the price of any example that escaped circulation.
History accounts for the rest.
The Flying Eagle Cent was the first small cent produced by the US Mint and paved the way for the modern penny we use today.
The short run and the small 1856 production are why the date stays expensive even in low grades.
Rarity Factors

When it comes to determining the rarity of the 1856 Flying Eagle Cent, there are several factors to consider.
These factors include mintage, survival, and condition.
Mintage
PCGS records at least 634 pieces struck in 1856 for presentation to members of Congress and other dignitaries.
That is the smallest production figure in the small cent series.
Survival Rate
Survival is harder to pin down than mintage. PCGS notes that more 1856-dated pieces were restruck from the original dies in 1858 and 1859, so the number of coins available to collectors is larger than 634, and a coin dated 1856 is not automatically one of the originals.
Condition
The condition of the 1856 Flying Eagle Cent is a significant factor in its rarity.
Most survivors show real wear, and problem-free pieces are the exception.
That is what makes a sharp example worth chasing: there are few of them.
The rarity comes from three things together: the small 1856 production, the wear on most survivors, and the number of pieces that come to market each year.
While the coin is not the rarest in the world, it is still highly prized by collectors and is an essential part of American numismatic history.
Mintage and Survival Estimates

Mintage Numbers
The 1856 Flying Eagle Cent marked the introduction of the first small-sized one-cent coin by the United States Mint.
This coin was crafted from a copper-nickel composition and featured the design work of James B. Longacre.
Mint Director James Ross Snowden had the pieces struck and distributed without formal authorization from Congress, which is why the 1856 sits awkwardly between pattern and regular issue in the reference books. Heritage and Coin World put total production at around 1,500 when later restrikes are included.
That origin is the reason authentication matters more here than for an ordinary date. A piece offered as an original should be judged on its die state and surfaces, not on the date alone.
Survival Estimates
The 1856 owes its following to that small production.
It remains the lowest production quantity among all dates in the small cent series.
Survivors turn up regularly, but most sit in the lower grades, which is why clean examples draw so much attention.
High-grade examples are the hard part. They reach auction only occasionally, and buyers compete for them when they do.
Serious money appears whenever a strong example crosses the block.
Market Value and Auction Records
| Grades | Retail price, October 2023 (USA Coin Book) |
|---|---|
| Good (G-4) | $8,715 |
| Very Good (VG-8) | $9,902 |
| Fine (F-12) | $12,130 |
| Very Fine (VF-20) | $14,204 |
| Extremely Fine (EF-40) | $15,483 |
| About Uncirculated (AU-50) | $16,995 |
| Uncirculated (MS-60) | $18,763 |
| Brilliant Uncirculated (MS-63) | $28,597 |
| Proof (PR-63) | $20,437 |
The market for this date is thin.
Examples do not sit in dealer cases for long, and the asking price at that level is rarely a bargain.
USA Coin Book listed circulated examples at roughly $8,000 to $16,000 as of October 2023. Its current page puts an average example near $9,300 and uncirculated pieces at $20,100 to $30,600.
Uncirculated pieces ran from $18,000 to $28,000 in that same table, with proof coins around $20,000 at PR-63.
The auction record now stands at $312,000: a PCGS Proof 67+ example with a CAC sticker, classified Snow-3, sold by Heritage in November 2024. It had brought $240,000 in the same firm’s 2020 Simpson collection sale. A PCGS MS-66 piece in the same 2024 auction realized $192,000.
Wholesale sheets quote lower numbers than retail guides, so the gap between them is normal. A quote that looks like a bargain against retail is usually a sign that the coin has a problem.
Prices move with grade, eye appeal, and how many pieces are on offer in a given month.
Check sold prices from more than one source before you commit, and treat any single quote as a starting point.
Before you go…
The 1856 Flying Eagle cent earns its place in a collection on the history, but the entry price means the coin has to be right. Buy authenticated examples, compare sold prices, and walk away from anything with unexplained surface changes.
Related Articles: